Source : The Star
Tuesday February 10, 2009
VALLEY VIEWS WITH ELAN PERUMAL
THE relocation of the Klang transportation operation from the town centre to the Klang Sentral in Meru, about 10km away, is fast making the state and local authorities lose the goodwill of the public.
The latest of a series of peaceful demonstrations against the move was held outside the Plaza MPK next to the old North Klang bus terminal last Saturday.
The protesters comprising bus operators and drivers, commuters, traders and residents vented their anger on the Klang Municpal Council (MPK) with all sorts of messages on banners, placards and posters condemning the authorities.
Some of the more telling messages on their 40-plus banners, placards and posters are “Don’t turn the royal town into a ghost town”, “Don’t let the North Klang bus terminal become a graveyard” and “We are not animals to be chased away as you like’’.
Surely, the authorities should realise by now that their unpopular and unwise decision to shift the bus terminal operation to the RM12mil custom-built transport hub is causing much damage to their relationship with the general public, in particular the majority low-income group who are dependent on public transport to get around.
There are several reasons the move is unwise, unreasonable and unacceptable.
First, the location is too far for the poor commuters who are generally residents in and around the town centre. To board a bus to travel to their destination, they will have to go the Klang Sentral in Meru, about 10km away. They will need to board a bus in town to get to Meru, costing them extra financial burden and wasting valuable time.
Secondly, the location of the new transport hub is certainly not too appropriate as Meru is by all accounts a modern township with its residents being relatively well-off, comprising people of the middle and upper classes. These people do not need to depend on public transport as almost all of them have cars.
It is the low-income and the poor living in and around the Klang town centre who really depend on the public transport system to get around. The old North Klang terminal has been an economic lifeline for most of them.
Thirdly, the contention that the relocation of the public transport operation is necessary to ease the daily traffic havoc in the royal town does not hold water.
The daily traffic chaos in Klang is not caused by the existence of the bus terminal, but by the ad hoc road works and the current major road projects in and around the town. If and when the road works are properly organised and managed and the mega road projects completed, the congestion in Klang will certainly be history or at least be under control and managable.
As a long-time resident of Klang myself, I find it rather strange for the authorities to embark on such an irrational move.
I have never before experienced or encountered so many people expressing anger and dissatisfaction against the authorities, especially the MPK, over anything like the way they are reacting to the relocation move.
Take the express bus operators for example. I had never expected them to be so vocal and visible in their opposition to the relocation move.
Last Thursday, they held a protest after refusing to drive their buses into terminal A of the Klang Sentral. They were frustrated over the lack of commuters at the new hub.
There were at least four other such demonstrations around the district, including those at Jalan Taiping in North Klang and Kapar since the Klang Sentral transport hub was opened on Dec 27 last year.
From the tone of the messages sent through their protest posters and placards, the people just don’t want what used to be the hustling-bustling town centre to become a ghost town.
They believe that the move will result in some 1,000-odd businesses around the former terminal area dying an unnatural and unwarranted death.
Besides the shops and stalls at Jalan Pos, Jalan Pos Baru, Jalan Batu Tiga Lama, Lorong Kepayang and the Persiaran Sultan Ibrahim, more than 150 traders from the Plaza MPK are also facing a bleak time, with some expecting their shops to close.
A businessman, who wants to be identified only as Eng, asked why the MPK was “killing” its own projects such as the Plaza MPK and the old bus terminal.
Eng pointed out that the MPK had invested millions of ringgit to build the Plaza MPK in which the superstore Mydin is the anchor tenant.
He said the complex would become insignificant and dead without the bus terminal.
“I cannot understand the MPK rationale, spending RM700,000 to build the open-air bus terminal and then close it down after just two years,” Eng said.
“And the council is willing to jeopardise these projects implemented with public funds in order to ensure the success of a private project,’’ he said.
Eng is correct. The question of accountability, transparency and good governance of the MPK must be evaluated as almost RM150mil of public money has apparently gone down the drain.
It seems that over the past five years, the MPK has wasted millions of ringgit on projects that have not really benefited the public and it has been reported that it relied heavily on bank facilities to operate its day-to-day affairs.
Klang Traders Association chairman Abdul Rani Moin, who was among one of the protesters last Saturday, stressed that the traders and the commuters were not against development but the MPK had handled the situation poorly.
He said the authorities had caused a lot of misery to the traders and the commuters.
“The authorities had gone all out to ensure the bus operation is moved out of Klang town and we don’t understand why they are doing it at all costs.
“The MPK is doing it at the expense of the traders who have been here for decades and the commuters,’’ Rani said.
MPK president Mislan Tugiu had nonchalantly told me recently that the people would resist any change and this was exactly what was happening on the controversial relocation.
Mislan said it was just a matter of getting used to the new arrangement as the council felt that this was the best solution to resolve the traffic problem in the town.
However, most Klang residents will agree that the current traffic congestion in town is being caused by the construction of a flyover at Persiaran Sultan ibrahim,
To shift the operation of bus services to Meru is surely not a very intelligent thing to do, especially when the local route buses and the Klang-KL buses are concerned.
Does it make sense if someone in the Klang town wanting to go to KL has to travel about 10km to the Klang Sentral to board a KL-Klang bus which then travels back 8km via the Federal Highway to KL?
This means travelling nearly an extra 18km one-way and also being subjected to a delay of about 40 minutes each time.
How can the authorities explain why commuters had to undergo this sort of treatment in the name of development and change?
The MPK is obviously refusing to listen to the voice of the people and has even threatened to flex its muscle on the bus operators if they do not toe the line,
The commuters, business operator and the NGOs are, however, hoping that the Selangor state government will intervene to rectify the situation.
Their only hope lies in the hands of Selangor Mentri Besar Tan Sri Abdul Khalid Ibrahim who in December last year had directed the MPK to restructure the services of the buses by the end of this month.
Till than, I’ll keep my fingers crossed and hope that justice will be done in the best interests of the thousands of commuters in the royal town.
The bus stops at your office, Tan Sri, and we pray you know what to do for our well-being.